Toaster Buying Tips

Most toasters on the market offer more or less similar basic functions that include bagel, defrost and reheat settings. However, an expensive model doesn’t necessarily give you a better toasting performance than a cheaper one since you’re actually paying more money for features such as stylish design and certain special settings such as reheat, keep warm and and countdown timer, etc.

Below is a list of items you’ll want to know before buying a toaster:

1. How many slices can it toast?

Most models on the market can toast two slices at once, while some (pricier) models can toast 4 slices. The number of slices (and the time it takes to toast them) will be important especially for users who have families of 3 or 4. These users may want to be able to toast 4 slices at once as it allows them to serve the whole family at once.

How large are the slots?

One of the most important things is the width of the slots. While most toasters can hold normal sized (commercial) slices, homemade bread slices tend to be longer and/or wider and not fit in normal sized slots.

3. Is the browning easy to adjust and consistent?

One of the things that annoy people most is a toaster which leaves one batch untoasted while almost charring the next. Make sure to pick a model which can produce nicely and evenly toasted slices every time.

4. How many controls are there? Are there separate controls for slots?

Some models come with many control options (defrost, bagel, etc.) and even have separate controls for each slot. Extra controls also mean higher prices.

5. Is there a high lifting feature?

Most models nowadays are equipped with a high lift feature which makes it easy to take the slices from the toaster and eliminates the risk of touching hot parts and burning fingers.

6. Is the housing cool to the touch?

In some older models, the housing tended to get hot, posing a risk of burning the user’s hands or fingers. It would especially pose a threat to little kids. Luckily this problem doesn’t exist in decent models today.

7. Is there a lift-and-look feature?

Some new, advanced and pricier models offer a lift-and-look feature that allows the user to check the slices visually without stopping the cycle. This is kind of an “extra” feature that is only included in a few models at the moment.

However it’s not an essential feature after all, and most consumers can live without paying extra money for that feature.

8. Is there a “little bit more” option?

Just like the lift-and-look feature, the “little bit more” option is an extra that is included in some advanced models. This is actually a short cycle that you can use to brown the slices “a little bit more” without risking to burn them.

9. Is the crumb tray easy to remove and clean?

The only user maintenance a toaster will require is to remove and clean the crumb tray from time to time. It is therefore important that the tray is easy to remove and clean. Most models on the market have easily removable trays.

10. How much counter space does it take? Does it look good on the counter?

And last but not least, unlike most other appliances, toaster generally remain on the counter or on a shelf and not stored away. It is hence important that it doesn’t take up too much counter space and look good.

However, most manufacturers spend a lot of thoughts and effort to create visually attractive models, so it’s unlikely that you’ll encounter with an ugly model.

Which to buy?

Best Low Cost Toaster: Hamilton Beach Ensemble SmartToast Extra-Wide Slot Toaster 22323

    Hamilton-22323

  • Affordable price
  • 900-watt 2 slice toaster
  • On-board toast tong set included – so that users don’t burn their fingers when removing toast
  • Cool touch exterior
  • Automatic shutoff if toast gets jammed
  • Toasts bagels, English muffins and other breads
  • Control – Bagel, cancel and defrost buttons
  • Learn more

Best Overall Toaster: Breville BTA830XL Die-Cast 4-Slice Long Slot Smart Toaster

    BTA830XL

  • Quite pricey
  • Extra-wide slots, 4-slice capacity for any shaped bread
  • 1600-watt heating element
  • Easy to use
  • Produces consistent and evenly browned results
  • Lift & Look feature which raises the toast slices for you to see whether it’s toasted to the desired level, and then gently lowers it back down
  • LED toasting progress indicator
  • Toast ready sound alert can be adjusted to High, Low or Mute
  • Learn more

Best Value Toaster: Cuisinart CPT-440CH Touch to Toast Leverless 4-Slice Toaster

    Cuisinart-CPT-440CH

  • A motorized control lowers items into 4 extra wide slots with the touch of a button
  • Dual control panels, with blue backlit LCD displays and countdown timers, control two slots each
  • One-sided enhanced bagel toasting
  • Reheat and defrost controls
  • Audible alert signal
  • 7 shade settings
  • 3 year limited warranty
  • Learn more

See More Toasters